Journal Search Engine
Search Advanced Search Adode Reader(link)
Download PDF Export Citaion korean bibliography PMC previewer
ISSN : 1225-5009(Print)
ISSN : 2287-772X(Online)
Flower Research Journal Vol.26 No.3 pp.90-101
DOI : https://doi.org/10.11623/frj.2018.26.3.02

Propagation Techniques for Ornamental Succulents

Raisa Aone M. Cabahug1, Sang Yong Nam1, Ki-Byung Lim3, Jae Kyung Jeon4, Yoon-Jung Hwang1,2*
1Department of Environmental Horticulture, Sahmyook University, Seoul, 01795, Korea
2Department of Convergence Science, Sahmyook University, Seoul, 01795, Korea
3Department of Horticulture Science, Kyungpook National University, Daegu, 41566, Korea
4Golden Seed Project National Agency for Crop Seed Improvement, National Institute of Crop Science, Wanju, 55365, Korea
Corresponding author: Yoon-Jung Hwang Tel: +82-2-3399-1718 E-mail: hyj@syu.ac.kr
05/06/2018 22/08/2018 27/08/2018

Abstract


The popularity of succulents as ornamental plants has increased in recent years. This is primarily because of their unique geometric shapes, which form a rosette, coupled with their ability to retain high levels of moisture. These features make ornamental succulents suitable as landscape plants as they can withstand extreme conditions and as potted plants for indoor spaces as they require minimal watering. Appropriate propagation techniques are important to increase production rates and plant quality in the shortest time possible. These ornamental plants may be propagated in various ways, both sexually, via seeds, and vegetatively, through a number of methods, such as stem cuttings, leaf cuttings, and micropropagation. In this review, methods for the propagation of ornamental succulents are described, including post-propagation care and management. Propagation aspects on which limited information is available are also highlighted. Potential areas for research required to produce data to further improve techniques, conservation, and rapid propagation efforts are discussed.



초록


    National Research Foundation of Korea
    2017R1C1B5017830

    Introduction

    Ornamental plants are used primarily for aesthetic purposes, which is an important aspect of human life (Dewir 2016; Kravanja 2006). They can be observed in public areas including schools, shopping areas, workplaces, and along the streets, where they are used to decorate open and indoor spaces (Ciesla 2002). Various locations that require landscaping have diverse conditions in terms of lighting, temperature, relative humidity, and moisture (Edmond et al. 1978). The choice of ornamental plant for specific environments is a key decision for interior designers, landscapers, as well as homeowners (Baldwin 2013). Succulents, among ornamental plants, have recently gained popularity as a landscape and pot plant (Baldwin 2007; Graham 1987).

    Often associated with semi-arid conditions (Graham 1987), succulents exhibit physiological tolerance to drought by storing water in fleshy assimilatory organs (Edwards and Ogburn 2013). Considered as Crassulacean Acid Metabolism (CAM) plants, succulents and cacti close their stomata and exhibit CO2 fixation during the day and under hot temperatures, and open their stomata during the cool night, and exhibit CO2 assimilation (Erwin 2009; Herrera 2009; Lee 2010).

    Presently, succulents are commercially produced and have increased in popularity among plant collectors, landscapers, and interior designers (Altman 2011; Walters et al. 2011; Weber 2003). Succulents have been in high demand because of specific characteristics, and are both practical and efficient as they are drought resistant and can survive even under minimal light making them suitable for indoor use (Alaspa 2016; Bell 2001; Nefzaoui 2007). Coupled with their architectural, sculptural, and geometric shapes, succulents provide clear and simple lines that can be made into bizarre, eye-catching, and collectible arrangements (Baldwin 2013).

    According to Nyffeler and Eggli (2010), 12,500 species of succulents have been recognized from 690 genera. These species are commonly identified within the families. However, they can also be classified as stem or leaf succulents depending on which plant organ stores moisture (Rowley 1978). These organs are identified as they are slightly thicker and are the rounded structures of the plant (Kelaidis 2008). Succulents are considered for ornamental use, especially those belonging to the Crassulaceae and Mesembryanthemaceae (Graham 1987; Rowley 1978).

    Grown and globally distributed in all habitat types, succulents are utilized for more than just for aesthetic purposes; they are also cultivated for their environmental benefits (IUCN 1997). More studies have been conducted investigating the utilization of succulents for green-roofing systems among Sedum species (S. acre, S. oryzifolium, S. kamtschaticum, S. reflexum, S. rupestre, and S. spurium ‘Green Mental,’) (Kim et al. 2010). Studies have also been performed on the use of succulents for ground cover, green roofs, and walls for extreme conditions, highlighting their tolerance to cold and drought (Van Woert et al. 2005) These green roofing systems aim to provide vegetation with added environmental benefits in an urban environment by enriching biodiversity using efficient and high-surviving plants (Li and Yeung 2014).

    These plants have also gained attention in medical fields as potential sources of raw materials for medication. Studies of three Echeveria species from Mexico (E. craigiana, E. kimnachii, and E. subrigida) are being analyzed for antioxidant α-glycosidase inhibitors as well as anti-bacterial properties. Antioxidant compounds such as β-carotene, ascorbic acid, α-tocopherol, total phenolic, and flavonoids, and in vitro antioxidants (DPPH, ABTS, ORAC, and β -carotene bleaching [β-CBM]) have been found in the succulent extracts (Angulo et al. 2014). Other succulents have been further studied to play a potential role as a treatment for obesity (Habeck 2002).

    Because of their influence on human health and the environment, succulents are desired to be propagated rapidly and in large quantities. Plant propagation is performed to perpetuate species, multiply species, and maintain their youthfulness, and can be achieved via sexual and asexual reproduction (McNeilan and Gorman 2013; Sorensen 2015).

    The chosen method must be able to perpetuate plants in the shortest amount of time while maintaining the quality of the plants. The technique must also take into consideration not to harm the mother plant as much as possible. Various plants, even those that belong to the same family or genus may require a different technique. Likewise, mastering the traditional propagation tools used may open to the possibility of using a more advanced propagation technique that are available for similar crops. Thus, the proper knowledge and appropriate plant propagation technique is essential to produce new plants.

    Previous studies have shown that plant propagation of succulents can be performed in numerous ways. This review aims to identify and summarize available and published research on the multiplication process of ornamental succulents through both sexual and vegetative propagation methods. Finally, the management and care of plant propagules to maximize the growth and development of newly propagated ornamental succulents including appropriate conditions are likewise discussed in this paper.

    Propagation Techniques

    Because of the high market demand for succulents, the need to use appropriate propagation techniques for particular families or species is deemed necessary. Generally, propagation techniques for succulents can be divided into two main categories, sexual and asexual propagation. The latter does not involve the sexual process. Asexually propagated plants remain pure or genetically identical from one generation to the next. Conversely, the sexual process involves meiosis, which is the process that creates natural genetic variability (Acquaah 2009; Beyl and Trigiano 2014). The sexual method involves the production of new plants from seeds; whereas asexual or vegetative propagation involves techniques that make use of stems and leaf cuttings, and the separation of suckers and rhizomes. A more rapid method, which is still categorized as vegetative propagation, is in vitro culture or micropropagation.

    These methods are discussed in this review, including their care and maintenance as well as their advantages and disadvantages regarding a particular technique in the propagation of ornamental succulents.

    Sexual Propagation

    To produce food, fiber, and other raw products, majority of the agricultural plant propagation relies on seed and seedling methods. Thus, seed propagation is considered to be a cornerstone for the production of valuable agronomic and horticultural plants (Hartmann et al. 2011). This method increases genetic variation, forming hybrids with superior qualities. Plants from seeds also exhibit superior quality compared with vegetatively produced plants, which may exhibit a prolonged lifespan and be disease or virus free (Adams and Early 2004).

    Seed Propagation of Succulent Plants

    The use of seeds to propagate succulents is not common. However, most recent articles published using seeds are limited to the Cactaceae and Kalanchoe families (Mihalte et al. 2011; Rethy et al. 1987; Rojas-Arechiga and Vazquez-Yanes 2000). The key characteristic associated with the propagation of succulents through seeds is their minute size. Numerous studies have reported varying seed sizes, including those of E. gibbiflora at 0.75 mm (Parra et al. 1993), E. yalmanantlanensis at 0.39–0.90 mm (Vazquez-Garcia et al. 2013), Bossfeldi, and Strobocactus at ≤0.5 mm, and Nyctocereus and Opuntia at ≥ 0.5 mm diameter (Rojas-Arechiga and Vazquez-Yanes 2000). Sedum succulents propagated through seeds include S. acrem, S. album, S. kamtschatticum, and S. reflexum (Monterusso et al. 2005).

    The seeds are harvested when the flowers have been successfully pollinated and have matured (Hartmann et al. 2011). However, the majority of succulent and cacti are self-sterile, and many propagators are able to produce new hybrids using natural pollination (using male pollen from one species to fertilize a flower from a different species) (Harland and Harland 1981). Flowers are left to dry and ripen before tan-colored seeds are removed (Bregman and Bouman 1983).

    Asexual Propagation

    Also known as vegetative propagation, asexual propagation is based on the principle of totipotency (Adams and Early 2004), which is defined as “the properties of an individual cell (not a group of cells), with the two meanings of this term roughly corresponding to the progressive restriction in potential cells exhibited during normal development” (Condic 2014). However, Hartmann et al. (2011) simplified this statement to state that any plant cell has the capability to develop into a completely new plant. Considering this, several plant parts, such as the leaves, buds, nodes and internodes, buds, scion, cuttings, layer, bulb corm, tuber, and explants, may be used for vegetative propagation, and vary between plants (Li et al. 2013; Poethig 2013).

    Vegetative propagation is a suitable option for the propagator to maintain the genetic integrity of the plant, and assures true-to-type propagated plants (Hartman et al. 1990; Hogberg 2003), which means that they will produce new plants that are always genetically identical to the parent or clone (Toogood 1999). For succulents, the methods available for vegetative propagation include stem and leaf cuttings, suckers, and micropropagation.

    Propagation by Cuttings

    Generally, the use of cuttings for propagation is the most frequently used method for succulents, and is easy to perform (Baldwin 2013). Likewise, when there is an immediate condition under which succulents are affected by pest and diseases, cuttings may be used for rescue and are the last resort for the retention of succulent plants (Kapitany and Schultz 2004). Two kinds of cuttings are practiced for succulent plants, stem cuttings and leaf cutting.

    These propagation methods are made possible by the existence of meristematic tissues in certain parts of the plants (Ichihashi and Tsukaya 2015; Machida et al. 2013); specifically, the intercalary meristems, which are actively dividing cells located in the internodes or bases of the leaves. These are usually found in monocotyledonous plants (Evans and Perez 2004). These meristems can produce new plants, providing shoots and roots. Thus, stem and leaf cuttings can be used in propagation techniques.

    Stem Cuttings

    A study conducted by Mihaela et al. (2011) reported the rooting of stem cuttings of various succulent species (Aeonium domesticum, Aeonium tortuosum, Kalanchoe rhombopilosa, Kalanchoetubiflorum, Senecio articulatum, and Senecio jacobsenii) including valuable ornamental and medicinal cactuses, such as those belonging to the Optunia species (Stintzing and Carle 2005). Respective genera exhibit differences in rooting time namely with Senecio (21 days), Aeonium and Crassula (28 days), Sedum (39 days), and Kalanchoe (53 days).

    Each stem-cutting propagule is taken by making a cut on the lower portion of the mother plant or the sucker, approximately 3 – 6 cm long. This allows the mother plant to develop side shoots. The stem-cutting propagule is separated from the mother plant using a sharp tool, forming a slanted sharp surface. The stem must be cut in a way that generates about 4 – 5 nodes or leaves. Unlike other ornamental crops, succulents do not require the removal of leaves during stem-cutting propagation.

    Based on above mentioned study, stem cuttings take longer to produce a proper root system. Therefore, plant growth regulators are used to enhance the rooting process. The use of exogenous auxins, such as indole-3-butyric acid (IBA), indole-3-acetic acid (IAA), and naphthalene-3-acetic acid (NAA) are used to promote rooting among hardy stem cuttings.

    Conversely, according to the results of Saniewski et al. (2014) regarding the use of auxin polar transport inhibitors among Crassulaceae species (Bryophyllum daigremontianum, Bryophyllum calycinum, Kalanchoeblossfeldiana, and Kalanchoetubiflora), the effect of the control or water alone was comparable to the effect of 0.2% IAA, IBA, and NAA, and of 0.2% 1-N-naphthylphthalamic acid (NPA). Successful total inhibition of rooting was only observed in cuttings treated with 0.2% 2,3,5-triiodobenzoic acid (TIBA) and methyl 2-chloro-9-hydroxyfluorene-9-carboxylate (Morphactin).

    Saniewski et al. (2014) recommended that stem cuttings are pre-soaked in compete Hoagland solution, which would increase the percent rooting by 20% compared with the control. Likewise, the study suggested that succulent where it is rather hardy or at the lower portions of the mother plant where mature stems are found, increases the chances of survival as well as the rooting rate by 50%.

    Leaf Cuttings

    Defying the growth of simple leaves, which are not capable of developing new roots, the shoots, succulents, semi succulents, and cacti are able to propagate through their leaves by differentiating leaf parenchyma or through the presence of intercalary meristematic activity (Donnelly et al. 1999; Evert 2006; Gorelick 2015). Because of this, succulents can propagate through leaf cuttings especially those of the Crassulaceae family (Hagemann 1932; Kerner and Oliver 1902). This method seems to be more popular than seed propagation due to the lengthy germination period; thus, cuttings and offsets are rooted first in nursery flats filled with potting mixes before being placed in gardens or replication areas (Baldwin 2013). The success of propagating succulents is unpredictable, and some growers and enthusiasts term the multiplication of plants using leaf cuttings a game of chance (Artichoker 2016; Tuttle 2012).

    Studies by Cabahug et al. (2016a) showed that when producing leaf cuttings, the lower leaves or leaves found at the base of the mother plant should be taken. Likewise, leaves should be properly removed without any scaring in order to increase the chances of successful bud and root imitation. After removing leaves from the mother plant, cuttings are used to develop calli and are placed in a dry location with indirect sunlight, preferably at room temperature (20 - 25°C); it takes about 5 – 7 days. or until the green part of the point of turns to light or dark brown. This study also showed that the cuttings are planted upright in the medium at the point of leaf removal. With this method, successful rooting, root development, and normal plantlets were grown from Echeveria spp., including E. ‘A Grimm One’, E. ‘Momorato,’E. pulvinata, and E. pulidonis. However, other guidelines for planting succulent leaf cuttings recommend that leaf cuttings should only be planted on soil when the leaf-cuttings have already developed roots during the callusing process.

    Conversely, in a study on ornamental Sansevieria trifasciata L. the use of different parts of the leaf cuttings (apical, middle, and bottom parts of the snake plant) for meristemoid production revealed no significant differences in the rooting, shooting, or proliferation of the plant. However, the use of dipping treatments such as 2000 mg・L-1 of IBA resulted in the highest rooting success (Sarmast et al. 2009).

    In a study by Cabahug et al. (2016b), plant growth hormones, IBA and kinetin, were used at different concentrations to enhance both rooting and shoot development, respectively, to target the unpredictability of organ development in E. subsessilis and E. runyonii. Researchers concluded by recommending the use of combined 100 ppm IBA and 100 ppm Kinetin for proper root and shoot development. However, IBA may be preferable when only a single application is used. In addition, alternative forms of exogenous auxin hormones, including BAP and NAA, were also used for Pachyeria pachytoides and Sedum morganianum leaf cuttings. The use of combined 4.0 mg・L-1 BAP and 0.1 mg・L-1 NAA resulted in a 100% regeneration success (Xu and Zheng 2017).

    Division or Separation of Suckers

    Limited studies have assessed the division or separation of suckers. This method of vegetative propagation involves the removal of new side shoots from the mother plant, which is a result of lateral shoot and rhizome growth. This has been commonly observed in aloe succulents (Gantait et al. 2014; Saggoo and Kaur 2010; Smith and Van Wyk 2009). Although this method is the most secure way of propagating vegetatively, it takes time, since the separation of side shoots may take months or years to reproduce through natural propagation (Hartmann et al. 1990).

    In this method, suckers, slips, or water sprouts may be taken from the mother plant. Suckers are adventitious shoots that emerge from a root or from the runners that grows near the mother plant, thus its name, while slips are offshoots that are formed from the peduncle of the mother plant. Similar to suckers and slips, waterspouts are shoots that emerge from a latent bud on the mother plant. (Bhende and Kurien 2015; Hartmann et al. 2011).

    Succulents usually develop suckers, slips, and water sprouts, but this kind of growth system is more commonly applied to Sempervivum species. Succulent plants belonging to this genus are popularly referred to as ‘hens and chicks’ or houseleeks due to the production of numerous suckers and slips (Alberti et al. 2007; Karaer et al. 2011), as well as for other Sedum species (Calie 1981; Sajeva et al. 2009). There is limited information regarding the hastening of side shoots for common genera of succulents using this propagation tool.

    Micropropagation or In-Vitro Propagation

    Micropropagation, or in vitro propagation, is used to rapidly propagate cultivars, and shows promise for the production of pathogen-free and virus-tested propagation sources (Hartmann et al. 2011). This modern method usually involves growing plant pieces (explants) in glass under sterile environmental conditions (Toogood 1999). Several ornamental crops have been grown using this method, especially those that are difficult to propagate (Ruchala 2002), in order to hasten production. This method has been successful for orchids (Chugh et al. 2009) and anthuriums (Matsumoto and Kuehnle 1997).

    A few studies have used this current fast-paced method in the propagation of succulents, with a particular focus on the factors affecting micropropagation, including the use of explants, media, callus induction, shoot regeneration and proliferation, growth conditions, and acclimatization. Famous families of succulents have been successfully micropropagated: Aizoaceae, Asphodelaceae, Asclepiadaceae, Crassulacea, and Euphorbiaceae (De Langhe et al. 1974; Fay et al. 1995; Gratton and Fay 1992; Karthik Prabu et al. 2013; Kim et al. 2017; Starling and Dodds 1983).

    a. Explants and Planting Materials

    In studies by Gratton and Fay (1992), a shoot with two dormant buds was chosen as an explant for Caralluma micropropagation. Explants were excised by carefully removing the areole using a vertical incision, with at least 3–5 mm of the surrounding tissue. However, the use of different tissue types may vary depending upon the species. Shoot-tips are used for Kalanchoe (Smith and Nightingale 1979) and Lithops (Rogers and Lineberger 1981), inflorescences for Hwarthia and Mammillaria (Kaul and Sabharwal 1972; Wyka et al. 2009), seed fragments for Agave (Groenewald et al. 1977) and Aloe (Groenewald et al. 1975), and leaves for Sansevieria (Adaci et al. 1976) and Echeveria (Raju and Mann 1970).

    These tissues are then treated and sterilized to minimize contamination. Lee et al. (2009), propagated Sedum sarmentosum using 70% (v/v) ethanol for 30 seconds, dipping in 0.5% sodium hypochlorite solution for 15 minutes, and rinsing four times with sterile water. Tissues were then left to be air-dried inside a laminar-flow cabinet for 30 min.

    A different method of explant sterilization was used for Caralluma difusa. First, tissues were washed with running tap water for 20 – 30 min, treated with 1% (v/v) Tween-20 for 10 min, and then rinsed twice with distilled water. These was further sterilized by placing tissues inside a laminar-flow hood and surface-sterilized with 60% (v/v) ethanol for 1 min and 0.01% (v/v) HgCl2 for 5 min. Then, tissues were washed thoroughly 6 – 8 times with sterile double-distilled water (Karthik Prabhu et al. 2013). Of note, tap water should be used sparingly, if at all, to rinse tissues or explants, as it may increase the possibility of contamination (Hartmann et al. 2011).

    b. Growing Media and Callus Induction

    Common to all published studies on the micropropagation of succulents is the use of the Murashige and Skoog’s medium (MS). This is prepared by mixing a premix powder or agar with 3% w/v of sucrose, and maintaining at pH 5.8 before autoclaving (Fay et al. 1995; Oh et al. 2017; Starling and Dodds 1983). A comparative study by Lee et al. (2009) on plant regeneration medium for S. sarmentosum revealed that the use of MS was more intensive compare with B5 medium (Gamborg et al. 1968).

    MS or basal medium is then supplemented with growth regulators or high concentrations of cytokinin and auxin. Different cytokinins (adenine sulfate, BA, 2iP, Ki, and zeatin) and auxins (IAA, IBA, NAA, and 4-amino-3,5,6-trichloropicolinic acid/ Picloram) have been used (Balch et al. 2015; Goldammer et al. 2003; Han et al. 2009; Lee et al. 2009). Studies on E. laui revealed that the use of 0.1 mg・L-1 NAA + 3.0 mg・L-1 was the most effective mixture for callus formation.

    c. Multiplication and Proliferation

    Over time, auxiliary buds will grow from the explants following preliminary planting in the medium. During this stage (explants with 2 – 3 asclepiads), samples were cut into sections with one bud per piece. Each piece is placed in a new separated container. These sections continue to produce lateral shoots and proliferate (Gratton and Fay 1992). Subculturing continues using this process at intervals of 1 – 2 months until sufficient shoots are observed. However, to hasten the multiplication process, the culture media is supplemented with plant growth regulators for subsequent subcultures in order to sustain nutritional needs and promote shoot and root formation (Hartman et al. 2011; Toogood 1999).

    Fortification of the MS medium during shoot multiplication and root proliferation was suggested by Kailmuthu et al. (2014) with the use of BAP for Caralluma diffusa. However, Gratton and Fay (1992) reported that combinations of NAA between 5 and 20 mg・L-1 are generally the most suitable for ornamental succulents.

    Similarly, a different mixture was used for leaf explants of Gasteria croucheri, which included a combination of 2.0 and 5 mg・L-1 NAA and was later supplemented with Ki to produce roots at the last subculture, and was later left to root in a hormone-free medium.

    The differences in the literature suggest that the use of hormones may differ for each species; therefore, the concentration and type of cytokinin and auxin should be evaluated for other high-valued ornamental succulent plants.

    Care and Maintenance

    Care of Seeds and Seedlings

    Boarder (1969) suggested that the best time to sow seeds is in April or when the weather is sufficiently warm and the location provides sufficient light. Conversely, Flores et al. (2016) found out that all succulent species in Mexico are considered as neutral photoblastic or neutral to light. However, some species (Mammillaria compressa, Agave salmiana, and other varieties of Derocactus latispinus) also exhibit higher germination under high light conditions.

    Fenner and Thompson (2005) emphasized that although they may be photoblastic, temperature requirements may be a key factor in germination, which is commonly associated with light. A temperature of 25°C is considered to be suitable to germinate seeds in a growth chamber as recommended for cacti, agave, and related succulent species (Nobel 1988). Other studies have reported that succulents within various families and species are capable of germinating under temperatures of 15 – 33°C in their natural habitat (Flores and Briones 2001; Pritchard and Miller 1995).

    Additionally, Zimmer (1971) and Nobel (1988) provided guidelines on the germination of succulent seeds. They noted that extremes of temperature (below 12°C and above 35°C) will decrease the germination rate. Following the planting of seeds of succulents, numerous recommendations have been made in terms of soil mixtures (Bach 1998; Kohlschreiber 1998).

    The use of compost mixed with enough sandy soil to protect the succulents from rot, facilitate proper drainage, and provide proper aeration, has been emphasized in previous studies (Graham 1987; Monterusso et al. 2005). When planting succulent seeds, it is advised not to cover the seeds with compost, as it should remain on the surface, with the exception of large-sized seeds. Relative to each species, seeds are able to germinate from 2 – 4 days to 3 – 5 weeks (Graham 1987; Harland and Harland 1981).

    When initiating seed growth, various techniques have been used to hasten germination. Gibberellic acid (GA3) was applied to Kalanchoe seeds to lessen the light requirement. However, traditionally, Kalanchoe seeds are incubated in KNO3 solution to prevent secondary dormancy (De Petter et al. 1985). In line with plant growth regulators, Mihalte et al. (2011) suggested treatment with 1.8% sodium nitrophenolate for 8 h for various Cactaceae species. Likewise, the use treatment with 9% naphthalene acetic acid (NAA) for 8 h in an aqueous solution was suggested for maximum germination. Pre-treatments are usually recommended only to increase the germination rate.

    Care for Succulent Cuttings and Suckers

    Propagation techniques for the potting medium of succulents were similar to those for the seed media. The use of 50% sand and 50% peat or compost is needed to provide cuttings with sufficient moisture and the ability to drain excess water (Ellern 1972).

    A more recent study by Oh et al. (2015) suggested the use of a 5 : 3 : 2 soil medium mixture of coco peat: peat moss: vermiculite for E. agavoides ‘romeo’, a 2.5 : 3 : 2 : 2.5 soil media mixture of coco peat: peat moss: vermiculite: sand for E. agavoides var. ‘cristata’ and E. ‘leibeulli’, which provided 87 – 90% rooting success for their respective species. It was also emphasized that whatever mixture was used to propagate stem cuttings should facilitate proper drainage in order to reduce the rotting of leaf and stem cuttings (Sorensen 2015).

    After planting, plants should not be exposed to direct sunlight, and if necessary the use of shading materials such as nets, burlap, or polyethylene shelters are used to protect from sudden and drastic changes in conditions (Fowler and Chaffee 2010; Semchenko et al. 2012)

    Recommended environmental conditions suggested by the results of previous experiment include temperatures of 15 – 30°C and relative humidity of 60 – 75% (Cabahug et al. 2016a; 2016b). Furthermore, succulent cuttings should not be drenched in water; a misting technique should be used as to provide sufficient moisture while reducing the probability of stem or leaf rotting, and may be watered every 4 – 5 days (Wiesner and Johnson 1977).

    Nam et al. (2016) recommended the use of supplemental lighting with an intensity of 120 μmol・m-2 ・s-1 for 6 h, in addition to natural light during the day. Higher quality of succulents (Sedeveria ‘Letizia,’ Sedum ‘Sun Red,’ Crassula rupestris, Echeveria ‘Momotaro,’ and Graptoveria opalina) based on height, diameter, and color were taken from high intensity and long duration exposure to LED light. Likewise, Cabahug et al. (2017) also recommended a high intensity level (150 μmol・m-2 ・s-1) to enhance the quality of E. agavoides and E. marcus. Succulents exposed to this level of light had higher visual quality, normal plant development, and intensified color, which corresponds to increased anthocyanin content.

    Studies on some areas of succulent care and management are lacking, such as plant nutrition and pest and disease control. Research in these areas is required, which may provide more information for maintaining the quality and proper environmental management for succulent species.

    Care for Micropropagated Succulents

    During the course of propagation, the use of sterile tools, medium, planting materials, and containers is necessary to reduce the contamination percentage (Balch et al. 2015). Upon completion of micropropagation in the lab, the cultures are grown in a separate lab under controlled conditions (Hartmann et al. 2011).

    It is recommended that micropropagated plants are incubated for at least 16 h under light and 8 h under dark conditions with fluorescent plants and about 15 μmol・m-2 ・s-1 for Echynocactus and Mammillaria species. However, a much higher light intensity was used in a study on the organogenesis of Ariocapus species with 50 μmol・m-2·s-1 at temperatures of 25°C (Balch et al. 2015; Goldammer et al. 2003)

    The success of micropropagation depends on the percent survival rate during the acclimatization stage. For aloes, Gupta et al. (2014) reported a 70% survival rate, for E. subsessilis a 50 – 70% survival rate (Oh et al. 2017), and for ornamental cacti an 85% survival rate (Balch et al. 2015).

    The plantlets are rinsed or teased from the medium, gently rinsed under running or distilled water to remove attached agar, and then planted in regular growing medium. Plantlets are then subjected to a hardening process wherein they are slowly introduced to light until they are able to withstand field or outdoor conditions (Hartmann et al. 2011). Notably, limited studies have investigated the incubation as well as the acclimatization of ornamental succulents.

    Conclusion

    The increased popularity of ornamental succulents indicates that there is a high demand for increased varieties, and for a higher supply of this unique and water-efficient ornamental crop. Several propagation techniques are available, which may be used by plant propagators and farm owners. Each species or genera may require different methods of care and management. However, based on this mini-review, several areas were identified that require further research, including: i) pre-treatment and planting of seeds on appropriate media and under environmental conditions; ii) cutting and soaking the leaf and stem using appropriate media mixtures; iii) division and separation of suckers, scar and growth treatments; iv) micropropagation trials for other common ornamental succulents and growth hormone mixed with the base media; and v) incubation and acclimatization protocols.

    Acknowledgement

    This work was supported by the National Research Foundation of Korea (NRF) grant funded by the Korea government (MSIT) (No. 2017R1C1B5017830).

    Figure

    Table

    Reference

    1. AcquaahG (2009) Horticulture: principles and practices. 4th ed.Pearson Prentice Hall, New Jersey, USA
    2. AdaciT , NojimaY , NagatomoT (1976) Plant redifferentiation from tissue culture of Sansevieria leaf. In Bull Fac Agric Miyazaki Univ 23:73-78
    3. AdamsCR and EarlyMP (2004) Principles of horticulture. Elsevier Butterworth-Heinemann Publication. Burlington, MA, USA
    4. AlaspaB (2016) The ultimate guide to succulents. Sep 2016, http://www.ambius.com/the-ultimate-guide-to-succulents
    5. AlbertiA , BlazicsB , KeryA (2007) Evaluation of Sempervivum tectorum L. flavonoids by LC and LC MS . ChromatographiaSupplement 68:107-111
    6. AltmanK (2011) At home with succulents. Altman Plants Inc.Vista, California, USA
    7. AnguloGL , AvilaJM , CamachoSP , Avi aRV , SantosYP , VargasFD (2014) Chemical composition and antioxidant, α-glucosidase inhibitory and antibacterial activities of three Echeveria DC. species from Mexico . Arabian Journal of Chemistry11:1-10
    8. ArtichokerJ (2016) Succulent: Structure and function. Sep 2016, http://www.microscopy.uk.org.uk/mag/artdec13macro/Artichoker_Article.pdf
    9. BachD (1998) Soils for succulents- a nurseryman s view . Cactus and Succulent Journal70:79
    10. BalchEP , DiazMS , MalagonRR , AlejoNO (2015) Tissue culture of ornamental cacti . Scientia Agricola72:540-561
    11. BaldwinDL (2007) Designing with succulents. Timber Press, Portland OR, USA
    12. BaldwinDL (2013) Succulents simplified: growing, designing and crafting with 100 easy care varieties. Timber Press Inc., Portland, London, UK
    13. BellSA (2001) Growing cacti and other succulents in the garden. Guild Master Craftsman Publications, USA
    14. BeylCA , TrigianoRN (2014) Plant propagation concepts and laboratory exercises. 2nd ed.CRC Press, Florida, USA
    15. BhendeSS , KurienS (2015) Sucker production in banana . Journal of Tropical Agriculture53:97-106
    16. BoarderA (1969) Cultural notes succulent and cacti . The Cactus and Succulent Journal of Great Britain31:2-203
    17. BregmanR , BoumanF (1983) Seed germination in Cactaceae Botanical Journal of the Linnean Society 86:357-374
    18. CabahugRA , SohSY , NamSY (2017) Effects of light intensity on the growth and anthocyanin content of Echeveria agavoides and E. marcus . Flower Res J25:626-269
    19. CabahugRA , SohSY , NamSY (2016a) Growth of Crassulaceae succulents as influenced by leaf cutting type and planting position . Flower Res J24:255-263
    20. CabahugRA , SohSY , NamSY (2016b) Effects of auxin and cytokinin application on leaf cutting propagation in Echeveria species . Flower Res J24:255-263
    21. CaliePJ (1981) Systematic studies in Sedum section Ternata (Crassulaceae) . Brittonia33:498-507
    22. ChughS , GuhaS , RaoIU (2009) Micropropagation of orchids: A review on the potential of different explants . Scientia Horticulturae122:507-520
    23. CieslaWM (2002) Non-wood forest products from temperate broad-leaves trees. Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations. Rome, Italy, pp 18-45
    24. CondicML (2014) Totipotency: what it is and what it is not . Stem Cells and Development23:796-812
    25. De LangheE , De BerghP , Van FijkR (1974) in vitro culture as means for vegetative propagation of Euphorbia pulcherrima. In Zeitschr. Pflanzenphysiol 71:271-274
    26. De PetterE , Van WiemeerschL , RethyR , DedonderA , FredericqH , Ja De Greef, SteyaertH , StevensH (1985) Probit analysis of low and very-low fluence-responses of phytochrome-controlled Kalanchoeblossfeldiana seed germination . Photochemistry and photobiology42:697-703
    27. DewirYH (2016) Cacti and succulent plant species as phytoplasma hosts: A review . Phytopathogenic Mollicutes6:1-9
    28. DonnellyPM , BonettaD , TsukayaH , DenglerRE , DenglerNG (1999) Cell cycling and cell enlargement in developing leaves of Arabidopsis . Developmental Biology215:407-419
    29. EdmondJB , SennTL , AmdrewsFS , HalfacreRG (1978) Fundamentals of Horticulture. 4th ed.McGraw-Hill, Inc., pp 87-130
    30. EdwardsEJ , OgburnRM (2013) Plant venation: from succulence to succulents . Current Biology23:340-341
    31. EllernSV (1972) Rooting cuttings of saltbush (Atriplex halimus L.) . J Range Manage25:154-155
    32. ErwinJ (2009) Cacti: studies on introducing a new group of ornamental plants . Acta Hort813:359-364
    33. EvansLS , PerezRK (2004) Diversity of cell lengths in intercalary meristem regions of grasses: location of the proliferative cell population . Canadian J of Botany82: 115-122
    34. EvertRF (2006) Esau s plant anatomy: meristems, cells and tissues of the plant body their structure, function, and development (3rd edition). John Wiley, Hoboken, USA
    35. FayMF , GrattonJ , AtkinsonPJ (1995) Tissue culture of succulent plants - An annotated bibliography . Bradleya13:38-42
    36. FennerM , ThompsonK (2005) The Ecology of Seeds. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, UK
    37. FloresJ , BrionesO (2001) Plant life-form and germination in a Mexican inter-tropical desert: effects of soil water potential and temperature . Journal of Arid Environments470:485-497
    38. FloresJ , Gonzales-SalvatierraC , JuradoE (2016) Effect of light on seed germination and seedling shape of succulent species from Mexico . Journal of Plant Ecology9:174-179
    39. FowlerJ , ChaffeeL (ed) (2010) General information on propagation by stem cuttings. University of California Davis, California, USA
    40. GamborgOL , MillerRA , OjimaK (1968) Nutrient requirement of suspension cultures of soybean root cells . Experimental cell Research50:151-158
    41. GrattonJ , FayMF (1992) in vitro propagation of succulent plants Methods in Molecular Biology. Humana Press Inc., Totowa, New Jersey, USA
    42. GantaitS , SinniahUR , DasPK (2014) Aloe vera: a review update on advancement of in vitro culture . Agr Scand B Soil Plant Sci64:1-12
    43. GrahamV (1987) Growing succulent plants including cacti. Timber Press, Portland, Oregon, USA
    44. GoldammerKG , RosasMM , AvilaVM (2003) Organogenesis and somatic embryogenesis in Ariocarpus kotschoubeyanus (Lem.) K. Schum. (Cactaceae), an endemic and endangered Mexican species. in vitro cellular & developmental biology. Plant: journal of the Tissue Culture Association 39:388-393
    45. GorelickR (2015) Why vegetative propagation of leaf cuttings is possible in succulent and semi-succulent plants . Haseltonia20:51-57
    46. GroenewaldEG , KoelemanA , WesselsDC (1975) Callus formation and plant regeneration from seed tissue of Aloe pretoriensis Pole Evans. In Zeitschr. Pflanzenphysiol 75: 270-272
    47. GroenewaldEG , WesselsDC , KolemanA (1977) Callus formation and subsequent plant regeneration from seed tissue of an agave sp. (Agavaceae). In Zeitschr. Pflanzenphysiol 81:369-373
    48. GuptaS , SahuPK , SenDL , PandeyP (2014) In-vitro propagation of Aloe vera (L.) Burm. f . Br Biotechnol J4:806816
    49. HabeckM (2002) A succulent cure to end obesity . Drug Discovery Today7:208-209
    50. HagemannA (1932) Untersuchungen an Blattstecklingen . Gartenbauwiss6:69-195
    51. HanH , ZhangS , SunX (2009) A review on the molecular mechanism of plant rooting modulated by auxin . African Journal of Biotechnology8:348-353
    52. HarlandW , HarlandS (1981) Growing cacti and succulents. Kangaroo Press, Australia
    53. HartmannHT , KesterDE , DaviesJrFT (1990) Plant Propagation principles and practices. 5th ed.Prentice Hall, Upper Saddle River, NJ, USA
    54. HartmannHT , KesterDE , DaviesFT , GeneveRL (2011) Hartmann & Kester's plant propagation: Principles and Practices. 8th ed.Pearson Education, Ltd., Pearson Prentice Hall, USA
    55. HerreraA (2009) Crassulacean acid metabolism and fitness under water deficit stress: if not for carbon gain, what is facultative CAM good for? Annals of Botany103:645-653
    56. HogbergKA (2003) Possibilities and Limitations of vegetative propagation in breeding and mass propagation of Norway spruce. PhD-thesis, Acta Universitatis Agriculturae Sueciae
    57. IchihashiY , TsukayaH (2015) Behavior of leaf meristems and their modification . Frontiers in Plant Science6:1-8
    58. International Union for Conservation of Nature and Natural Resources (IUCN) (1997) Cactus and succulent plants
    59. KalimuthuK , Kalaiyarasi K, Parabakaran R, Sasikala T (2014) in vitro propagation of Caralluma diffusa (Wight) N.E. Br . British Biotechnology Journal4:164-172
    60. KapitanyA , SchultzR (2004) Succulents: propagation. Vic Schulz Publishing. Teesdale, Australia
    61. KaraerF , CelepF , EggliU (2011) A taxonomic revision of the Sempervivum davisii complex (Crassulaceae) . Nordic Journal of Botany29:49-53
    62. Karthik PrabhuM , SamyduraiP , SubbaiyanB , ThangapandianV , BinuT (2013) in vitro propagation of a rare succulent medicinal plant Caralluma diffusa (Wight) N.E.Br . Research in Plant Biology3:8-17
    63. KaulK , SabharwalPS (1972) Morphogenetic studies on Haworthia: establishment of tissue culture and control of differentiation . American Journal of Botany59:377-385
    64. KelaidisGM (2008) Tough plants for every climate: hardy succulents. Storey Publishing, North Adams, MA, USA
    65. Kerner von MarilaunA , OliverFW (1902) The natural history of plants: their forms, growth, reproduction, and distribution. Volume 2. The history of plants. Blackie & Son, London, UK
    66. KimHH , LeeGY , ShinBE , LeeJH , SanchezPD , LeeSD (2017) Effect of plant growth regulators on in vitro callus formation and regeneration of Echeveria laui . Hortic Sci Technol35:206
    67. KimIH , HuhKY , HuhMR (2010) Cold tolerance assessment of Sedum s pecies f or s hallow -extensive green roof system . Korean J Hort Sci Technol28:22-30
    68. KohlschreiberD (1998) Soil mixes for epiphytic cacti . Cactus and Succulent Journal70:12-13
    69. KravanjaN (2006) Significant perceptual properties of outdoor ornamental plants . Acta Agriculturae Solvenica87:333-342
    70. LeeJS (2010) Stomatal opening mechanism of CAM plants . J Plant Biol53:19-23
    71. LeeSY , AhnJH , KimHS (2009) Factors influencing callus and shoot formation from in vitro propagation of Sedum sarmentosum . Hort Environ Biotechnol50:576-581
    72. LiWC , YeungKK (2014) A comprehensive study of green roof performance from environmental perspective . International Journal of Sustainable Built Environment3:127-134
    73. LiQ , DengM , ZhangJ , ZhaoW , SongY , LiQ , HuangQ (2013) Shoot organogenesis and plant regeneration from leaf explants of Lysionotus serratus D. Don . The Scientific World Journal280384:7
    74. MachidaY , FukakiH , ArakiT (2013) Plant meristems and organogenesis: the new era of plant developmental research . Plant Cell Physiol53:295-301
    75. MatsumotoTK , KuehnleAR (1997) Micropropagation of Anthurium. In: BajajYPS (ed)High-Tech and Micropropagation VI. Biotechnology in Agriculture and Forestry, vol 40. Springer, Berlin, Heidelberg, Germany
    76. McNeilanR , GormanR (2013) Plant Propagation. Oct 2016 https://www.uaf.edu/files/ces/districts/tanana/mg/manual/4-PlantProp.pdf
    77. MihaelaC , DoinaA , CarmenN , ManuelaM (2011) Research on the influence of the sampling periods on the propagation to cuttings at some succulent plants . Journal of Horticulture, Forestry and Biotechnology15:109-114
    78. MihalteL , SestrasRE , FesztG (2011) Methods to improve seed germination of Cactacea species . Bulgarian Journal of Agricultural Science17:288-295
    79. MonterussoMA , RoweDB , RughCL (2005) Establishment and persistence of Sedum sp. And native taxa for green roof applications . Hort Science40:391-391
    80. NamSY , LeeHS , SohSY , CabahugRAM (2016) Effects of supplementary lighting intensity and duration on hydroponically grown Crassulaceae species . Flower Res J24:1-9
    81. NefzaouiA (2007) Cactus to improve livestock feeding and income sources of the rural poor. Role of the FAO-Cactusnet. In: Priolo A, Biondi L, Ben Salem H, Mor and Fehr P (Eds) Advanced nutrition and feeding strategies to improve sheep and goat. Zaragoza, CIHEAM. Spain, pp 301-302
    82. NobelPS (1988) Environmental Biology of Agaves and Cacti. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, UK
    83. NyffelerR , EggliU (2010) An up-to-date familial and suprafamilial classification of succulent plants . Bradley28:125-144
    84. OhHG , GyeongJL , NamSY (2015) Comparison of rooting rate according to different cutting media on Echeveria . Korean J Hort Sci Technol33:202
    85. OhHG , LeeGJ , WonJ , NamSY , HongEY (2017) Regeneration according to plant growth regulator type . Hort Sci Technol35:206-207
    86. ParraV , VarggasCF , EguiarteLE (1993) Reproductive biology, pollen and seed dispersal, and neighborhood size in the hummingbird-pollinated Echeveria gibbiflora (Crassulaceae) . American Journal of Botany80:153-159
    87. PoethigRS (2013) Vegetative phase change and shoot maturation in plants . In Current topics in developmental biology105:125-152
    88. PritchardHW , MillerAP (1995) The effects of constant temperatures, light and seed quality on the germination characteristics of Agave americana . Bol Soc Bot Mex57:11-14
    89. RajuMVS , MannHE (1970) Regenerative studies on the detached leaves of Echeveria elegans: Anatomy and regeneration of leaves in culture . In Canad J Bot48:1887-1891
    90. RethyR , DedonerA , De PetterE , WiemeerschLV , FredericoH , De GreedJ , SteyaertH , StevesH (1987) Biphasic fluence-response curves for phytochrome-mediated Kalanchoe seed germination . Plant Physiology83:126-130
    91. RogersSMD , LinebergerRD (1981) The potential for differentiation and embryogenesis of Lithops in vitro . HortScience16:199
    92. Rojas-ArechigaM , Vasquez-YanesC (2000) Cactus seed germination: a review . Journal of Arid Environment44: 85-104
    93. RowleyG (1978) The Illustrated Encyclopedia of Succulents. Crown Publishers Inc., New York, USA.
    94. RuchalaSL (2002) Propagation of several native ornamental plants. Electronic Theses and Dissertations. May 2018 https://digitalcommons.library.umaine.edu/etd/448
    95. SajevaM , ColomboP , OddoE (2009) Preliminary studies on the anatomy of Sedum tenuifolium (S. Et S.) Strobl (Crassulaceae) . Plant Biosystems128:99
    96. SaggooMIS , KaurR (2010) Somaclonal variation in plants regenerated from cultures of two morphologically distinct accessions of Aloe vera Linn . Annals of Biological Research1:172-177
    97. SaniewskiM , GorajJ , Wergzynowicz-LesiakE , MiyamotoK , UedaJ (2014) Differential effects of auxin polar transport inhibitors on rooting in some Crassulaceae species . Acta Agrobotanica67:85-92
    98. SarmastMK , SalchiM , SalchiH (2009) The potential of different parts of Sansevieria trifasciata L. leaf for meristemoids production . Australian Journal of Basic and Applied Sciences3:2506-2509
    99. SemchenkoM , LepikM , GotzenbergerL , ZobelK (2012) Positive effect of shade on plant growth: amelioration of stress or active regulation of growth rate? Journal of Ecology100:459-466
    100. SmithR , NightingaleAE (1979) in vitro propagation of Kalanchoe . HortScience14:20
    101. SmithGF , Van WykB (2009) Aloes in Southern Africa. Struik Nature Press, CapeTown, South Africa
    102. StarlingRJ , DoddsJH (1983) Tissue-culture propagation of cacti and other succulents . Bradleya1:84-90
    103. StintzingFC , CarleR (2005) Cactus stems (Opuntia spp.): a review on their chemistry, technology, and uses . Mol Nutr Food Res49:175-194
    104. SorensenDC (2015) Plant Propagation. Oct 2016, https://extension.umaine.edu/gardening/mastergardeners/manual/propagation/plant-propagation/
    105. ToogoodA (ed) (1999) American horticulture society: plant propagation. A DK Publishing, New York, USA
    106. TuttleC (2012) Propagating succulents from leaves. Oct 2016, http://www.succulentsandsunshine.com/propagatingsucculents/ propagating-succulents-from-leaves-part-2
    107. XuX , ZhengW (2017) Hormone-injected leaf cutting, a new efficient in vivo multiplication protocol for two succulent plants . PeerJ Preprints7:1-7
    108. Van WoertND , RoweDB , AndresenJA , RughCL , XiaoL (2005) Watering regime and green roof substrate design affect Sedum plant growth . HortScience40:659664
    109. Vazquez-GarciaJA , JimenoD , CuevasR , ChazaroM , Muniz-CastroMA (2013) Echeveria yalmanantlanensis (Crassulaceae): a new species from Cerro Grande, Sierra de Manantl n, western Mexico . Brittonia65:273-279
    110. WaltersM , FigueiredoE , CrouchNR , WinterPJD , SmithGF , ZimmermannHG , MashopeBK (2011) Naturalized and invasive succulents of southern Africa . ABC Taxa11:370
    111. WeberE (2003) Invasive plant species of the world: a reference guide to environmental weeds. CABI publishing, Walllingford, UK, p 560
    112. WiesnerLE , JohnsonWJ (1977) Fourwing Saltbush (Atriplex canescens) propagation techniques . Journal of Range Management30:154-156
    113. WykaTP , W roblew ska M, H amerska M (2009) U se o f cactus flowers as explants for micropropagation . J Hort Sci Biotechnol84:454-458
    114. ZimmerK (1971) Ein weiterer Beitrag zur Keimung von Kakteensamen. Kakteen und andere Sukkulenten 22: 153 155